How to Build Analytical Skills for 11+ Comprehension

“What was the main character’s name?”

If only 11+ English Comprehension questions were that simple. In reality, your child is far more likely to face a question that requires a skill that goes far beyond simple fact-finding. This skill is analysis and inference.

It’s the ability to understand not just what happened, but why it happened and how the author conveyed that feeling. This is the single biggest challenge for many students, and it’s a key area examiners use to differentiate candidates.

At elevenplus.com, we know that analytical skill isn’t an innate talent; it’s a muscle that can be trained. This guide will provide you with the expert framework and practical tips you need to help your child learn to read like a detective, uncover hidden clues in any text, and construct top-scoring answers with confidence.

In this definitive guide, you will learn:

• The four key types of 11+ comprehension question.
• The powerful P.E.E. method for structuring the perfect inference answer.
• How to overcome the most common comprehension difficulties.
• Practical tips you can use at home to build these skills every day.

First, Understand the Four Types of Comprehension Question

Before going further into advanced analysis, it’s helpful to understand the landscape. Most 11+ comprehension questions fall into one of four categories:

1. Direct Retrieval: These are the most straightforward questions. The answer is stated directly in the text and can often be found and copied. (e.g. “What colour was the car?”)
2. Reading for Meaning (Vocabulary): These questions ask for the meaning of a specific word or phrase within the context of the passage. (e.g. “What does the word ‘exuberant’ mean in this sentence?”)
3. Analytical Comprehension: These questions require your child to use information from the text to explain why something happened or how something is portrayed.
4. Inference: These are the trickiest questions. The answer is not stated directly. Your child must use clues from the text to “read between the lines” and deduce an answer. (e.g. “From the character’s actions, what can you tell about their personality?”)

While all types are important, mastering Inference is the key to unlocking top marks. The rest of this guide will focus on a powerful method to do just that.

The P.E.E. Method: The Secret to a Perfect Inference Answer

The best way to teach inference is to give your child a structure for their answers. The P.E.E. method is a simple, memorable, and incredibly effective way to ensure their answers are detailed, justified, and hit all the key marking points.

• Point
• Evidence
• Explain

Let’s break it down.

P – Point

This is the main answer to the question. It should be a clear, concise statement that gets straight to the point.

E – Evidence

This is the proof. Your child must back up their point with a short quote or specific reference from the text. This shows the examiner they haven’t just guessed; they have found evidence for their idea.

E – Explain

This is the most important step. Your child must explain how or why their evidence proves their point. This is where they demonstrate true understanding by analysing specific words or phrases.

The P.E.E. Method in Action

Let’s use a short passage and a typical 11+ question to see how it works.

Text:

The ancient oak tree stood alone on the crest of the hill, its gnarled branches clawing at the bruised, purple sky. A bitter wind whipped around its trunk, tearing the last of its crimson leaves from their perches. Winter was coming.

Question: What impression does the author create of the scene?

A simple answer might be: “The author creates a sad or gloomy impression.” This is okay, but it wouldn’t score top marks.

Now, let’s use the P.E.E. method to build a high-scoring answer.

P – Point:

The author creates a harsh, gloomy, and slightly threatening impression of the scene.

E – Evidence:

The text describes the tree’s branches as “clawing at the bruised, purple sky” and mentions a “bitter wind.”

E – Explain:

The word “clawing” suggests the tree is aggressive and desperate, as if it’s in a fight. The sky isn’t just dark; it’s “bruised,” which makes us think of an injury, adding to the feeling of pain and hostility. Furthermore, the wind is described as “bitter,” which not only tells us it’s cold but also gives it an unkind, cruel personality.

This P.E.E. answer is powerful because it directly answers the question, provides proof, and explains the specific effect of the author’s word choices.

Common Comprehension Difficulties & How to Solve Them

Even with a great method, children can fall into common traps. Here’s how to help them climb out.

• The Problem: Treating it as a memory test.
  • The Solution: Train your child to refer back to the text for every single question. It’s an open-book test! The answer isn’t in their memory; it’s on the page. Encourage them to underline the evidence before they even start writing.
• The Problem: Being thrown by an unknown word.
  • The Solution: Teach them to read the rest of the sentence for context clues. Often, the meaning can be figured out from the words around it. If they are still stuck, advise them to make an educated guess and move on. Don’t let one word derail the entire paper.
• The Problem: Spending too long on one question.
  • The Solution: Look at the marks. If a question is only worth one mark, it requires a short answer. If it’s worth three marks, it likely requires a detailed P.E.E. response. Teach them to allocate their time accordingly and to come back to tricky questions at the end.

Three Ways to Build Analytical Skills at Home

You can help your child develop these skills every day, without it feeling like a formal lesson.

1. Ask “Why?” Questions During Reading When you read together, become a detective. Ask questions that go beyond the plot.

• “Why do you think the author used the word ‘whispered’ instead of ‘said’?”
• “What does that description tell us about how the character is feeling?”
• “What do you think might happen next, based on the clues in this paragraph?”

2. Build a “Wow Words” Vocabulary A wide vocabulary is essential for understanding nuance. When your child learns a new word (e.g. “melancholy”), don’t just learn the definition (“sad”). Discuss its flavour. How is it different from “unhappy” or “miserable”? A richer vocabulary allows for a more sophisticated analysis.

3. Read Widely and Voraciously Encourage your child to read different genres. A fantasy novel uses descriptive language differently than a historical story or a mystery. Experiencing a wide range of authorial styles will naturally improve their ability to analyse different texts and understand how writers create effects.

From Confusion to Confidence

Building analytical skills takes time and practice, but it is achievable for every child. By providing them with a clear framework like P.E.E. and encouraging them to think more deeply about the books they read, you can empower them to move beyond the surface of a text.

---

---

➡️ Explore our English Practice Packs today and give your child the tools they need to excel.